Outfield Options
The Melky Cabrera/Javier Vazquez trade created a hole in left field for the Yankees, and the options are somewhat limited thanks to a budget restriction. Now that Mark DeRosa, Jason Bay Matt Holliday and Marlon Byrd are virtually off the market, only a handful of options remain in the free agent pool. Let's take a look at the remaining options for left field:
Rick Ankiel
2009 Stats: .231 AVG/11 HR/38 RBI (STL)
2009 Salary: $2.8 million
Comments: Ankiel actually makes some sense for the Yankees in terms of ability and price. He'd slide nicely into the bottom of the batting order and his career 1.7 UZR in left field suggests he would not be a complete embarrassment in the outfield. He's likely to post better numbers in 2010 but I wonder if he has the makeup to play in New York.
Johnny Damon
2009 Stats: .282 AVG/ 24 HR/ 82 RBI (NYY)
2009 Salary: $13 million
Comments: The Yankees negotiated with Damon earlier this winter, but the outfielder's demands were too high. The affable Damon remains unsigned but if he was willing to take a one-year deal, the Yankees would likely bring him back. He'd serve as a major boost to the offense, but would he cause problems because of his reduced pay?
Jermaine Dye
2009 Stats: .250 AVG/ 27 HR/ 81 RBI (CHW)
2009 Salary: $11.5 million
Comments: Although the Yankees have been linked to Dye, I can't see them pursuing a 3X year-old Type-A free agent who is a defensive liability in the field. Dye would likely take a one-year deal, which helps his case, but the Yanks will probably look elsewhere.
Jonny Gomes
2009 Stats: .267 AVG/20 HR/51 RBI (CIN)
2009 Salary: $1.275 million
Comments: Gomes was obviously helped by Cinergy Field in 2009, but he could also serve as a cost-effective option for the Yankees. Gomes would add some power to the lineup and thanks to a career .307 AVG against lefties, Gomes could serve as a platoon partner for Brett Gardner. Mark down Gomes as a solid pick. Especially considering Shelley Duncan is no longer on the team.
Eric Hinske/Jerry Hairston Jr.
Hinske's 2009 Stats/Salary: .242 AVG/8 HR/25 RBI (PIT/NYY) - $1.5 million
Hairston's 2009 Stats/Salary: .251 AVG/10 HR/39 RBI (CIN/NYY) - $2 million
Comments: Both Hinske and Hairston were a great additions to the Yankee bench and performed well at the plate in limited appearances. Either player could act as a serviceable outfielder while splitting time with Gardner and Hoffman, but I worry about Hinske's defense and Hairston's durability.
Reed Johnson
2009 Stats: .255 AVG/4 HR/22 RBI (CHC)
2009 Salary: $3 million
Comments: The Yankees have already been connected to Johnson, and he'd be a good fit in the outfield thanks to his glove. If the price was fair he would be a good addition, but Brett Gardner could probably match Johnson defensively while adding speed to the lineup and at half the cost. Johnson would make a solid platoon option for Gardner.
Xavier Nady
2009 Stats: .286 AVG in 28 AB (NYY)
2009 Salary: $6.55 million
Comments: Nady has allegedly priced himself out of New York, which really raises a few questions. Firstly, how little are the Yankees looking to spend on an outfielder? Secondly, how much could a player who missed the 2009 season honestly ask for? Either way, there does not appear to be a match here, which is probably for the best. Nady would have been an injury concern going into 2010 anyway.
Scott Podsednik
2009 Stats: .304 AVG/7 HR/30 SB (CHW)
2009 Salary: > $1 million
Comments: Podsednik would be another excellent fit for the Yankees, adding speed to the bottom of the order and a solid glove in the field. He's basically Brett Gardner with more power and experience, but with a career .370 batting average against the Red Sox, the Yankees would be dumb to not take a look.
Randy Winn
2009 Stats: .262 AVG/2 HR/51 RBI (SFG)
2009 Salary: $9.6 million
Comments: Winn had an extremely down year in 2009, which could help the Yankees get him at a discount price. He's always had a solid glove and will likely post better numbers next season. The Yankees have shown interest in Winn in the past, so it would not surprise me if they went after him. Still, there are better options available.


